# No 58

- **MSHA mine ID:** 4608884
- **Status:** Abandoned
- **Type / commodity:** Underground / Coal (Bituminous)
- **Location:** Mcdowell, WV
- **Operator:** Pay Car Mining Inc
- **Controller:** James C  Justice III
- **Public source rows linked:** 9,146
- **Source coverage:** 17 / 20
- **Generated:** 2026-10-13T11:26:59.401Z

## Current entity hierarchy

**James C  Justice III (0171761) → Pay Car Mining Inc (0074803) → No 58 (4608884)**

Current identity source: `msha-mines`. This is a current snapshot, not a historical claim.

## Controller and operator valid-time history

- **Jeffrey K  Justus et al → Gapco Mining Company Inc:** 2001-03-01 through 2002-10-31; derived from co-tenure at mine 4608884; source `msha-controller-operator-history`.
- **O A  Stump Jr et al → Gapco Mining Company Inc:** 2002-11-01 through 2003-09-30; derived from co-tenure at mine 4608884; source `msha-controller-operator-history`.
- **Elizabeth  Stump → Corvus Mining Inc:** 2003-10-01 through 2004-01-25; derived from co-tenure at mine 4608884; source `msha-controller-operator-history`.
- **Jeffrey K  Justus et al → Corvus Mining Inc:** 2003-10-01 through 2003-09-30; derived from co-tenure at mine 4608884; source `msha-controller-operator-history`.
- **James C  Justice II et al → Walnut Coal Corporation:** 2004-01-26 through 2006-08-21; derived from co-tenure at mine 4608884; source `msha-controller-operator-history`.
- **James C  Justice II et al → Pay Car Mining Inc:** 2006-08-22 through 2009-05-06; derived from co-tenure at mine 4608884; source `msha-controller-operator-history`.
- **Mechel Oao → Pay Car Mining Inc:** 2009-05-07 through 2015-02-11; derived from co-tenure at mine 4608884; source `msha-controller-operator-history`.
- **James C  Justice II et al → Pay Car Mining Inc:** 2015-02-12 through 2017-06-20; derived from co-tenure at mine 4608884; source `msha-controller-operator-history`.
- **Jillean L  Justice et al → Pay Car Mining Inc:** 2017-06-21 through 2023-04-09; derived from co-tenure at mine 4608884; source `msha-controller-operator-history`.
- **James C  Justice lll et al → Pay Car Mining Inc:** 2017-06-21 through 2023-04-09; derived from co-tenure at mine 4608884; source `msha-controller-operator-history`.
- **James C  Justice III → Pay Car Mining Inc:** 2023-04-10 through current/open; derived from co-tenure at mine 4608884; source `msha-controller-operator-history`.

- History rows: 11
- Typed edges: 25
- Interval anomalies: 1
- Valid-time bounds: inclusive; date granularity; null end means open-ended in the upstream history row; not independent proof of present control.
- Transaction-time observation: 2026-10-13T11:19:05.459773+00:00.

## Assessment signals

1. **SAFETY — 0 since 2021:** Accidents and injuries 26 historical accident/injury rows; 0 coded fatalities and 1,733 lost days across the published record.
2. **COMPLIANCE — 9 since 2021:** Violations and penalties 1,961 violation rows across the full record; 613 carry an S&S flag and $1,936,288 appears in current assessed amounts.
3. **HEALTH — 2K samples:** Occupational health samples 1,505 coal dust; 64 coal quartz; 98 noise. 0 personal-sample rows have a published C/E ratio above 1; 4 noise rows have an action-level or PEL dose above 100%. These are separate measures, not a silica exceedance count. Silica results and sample status are shown separately.
4. **PRODUCTION — 0 tons:** Quarterly production and employment 0 employee hours and 0 summed average employees across reported subunits in the latest published quarter.
5. **LEGAL — 2,794 linked rows:** Contests, conferences and decisions 1,342 contested-violation rows, 1,338 civil-penalty docket/decision rows, and 114 conference records linked by issuance number.
6. **CONTRACTORS — 8 linked entities:** Contractors Contractors are linked through this mine’s violation or accident records. Their production and hours cover all their operations, so they are not included in this mine’s totals.
7. **INSPECTIONS — 8 since 2021:** Inspections 232 inspection events and 11K published inspection hours across the historical record.

## EIA annual operating context

No matched record in the 2024 EIA coal-public workbook. This may be inapplicable for a non-coal operation.

## Recent Title 30 crosswalk

Snapshot current through 2026-08-19.

- **30 CFR 75.1711 — Sealing of mines.** (2 retained recent rows) — https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-30/chapter-I/subchapter-O/part-75/subpart-R/section-75.1711
- **30 CFR 50.30 — Preparation and submission of MSHA Form 7000-2—Quarterly Employment and Coal Production Report.** (1 retained recent row) — https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-30/chapter-I/subchapter-I/part-50/subpart-D/section-50.30
- **30 CFR 77.502 — Electric equipment; examination, testing, and maintenance.** (2 retained recent rows) — https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-30/chapter-I/subchapter-O/part-77/subpart-F/section-77.502
- **30 CFR 48.31 — Hazard training.** (1 retained recent row) — https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-30/chapter-I/subchapter-H/part-48/subpart-B/section-48.31
- **30 CFR 77.1109 — Quantity and location of firefighting equipment.** (1 retained recent row) — https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-30/chapter-I/subchapter-O/part-77/subpart-L/section-77.1109
- **30 CFR 75.310 — Installation of main mine fans.** (1 retained recent row) — https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-30/chapter-I/subchapter-O/part-75/subpart-D/section-75.310
- **30 CFR 75.312 — Main mine fan examinations and records.** (1 retained recent row) — https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-30/chapter-I/subchapter-O/part-75/subpart-D/section-75.312
- **30 CFR 75.333 — Ventilation controls.** (1 retained recent row) — https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-30/chapter-I/subchapter-O/part-75/subpart-D/section-75.333
- **30 CFR 75.1714-3 — Self-rescue devices; inspection, testing, maintenance, repair, and recordkeeping.** (1 retained recent row) — https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-30/chapter-I/subchapter-O/part-75/subpart-R/section-75.1714-3
- **30 CFR 75.1202-1 — Temporary notations, revisions, and supplements.** (1 retained recent row) — https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-30/chapter-I/subchapter-O/part-75/subpart-M/section-75.1202-1

## Source coverage

- **Accident, Injuries, and Illnesses:** 26 rows; 2002-07-07 through 2018-07-11; source ID `msha-accidents`
- **Addresses of Record:** 1 rows; 2026-06-23 through 2026-06-23; source ID `msha-addresses`
- **Assessed Violations:** 1,907 rows; 2001-05-07 through 2024-03-25; source ID `msha-assessed-violations`
- **Civil Penalty Dockets and Decisions:** 1,338 rows; 2008-03-29 through 2021-12-09; source ID `msha-civil-penalty-dockets-decisions`
- **Coal Dust Samples:** 1,505 rows; 2001-05-17 through 2019-09-30; source ID `msha-coal-dust-samples`
- **Conferences:** 114 rows; 2001-06-28 through 2019-04-15; source ID `msha-conferences`
- **Contested Violations:** 1,342 rows; 2007-05-15 through 2021-01-06; source ID `msha-contested-violations`
- **Contractor Employment and Production — Quarterly:** 272 rows; unknown through unknown; source ID `msha-contractor-production-quarterly`
- **Contractor Employment and Production — Yearly:** 40 rows; unknown through unknown; source ID `msha-contractor-production-yearly`
- **Controller and Operator History:** 11 rows; 2001-03-01 through 2006-08-22; source ID `msha-controller-operator-history`
- **Inspections:** 232 rows; 2001-03-26 through 2026-06-23; source ID `msha-inspections`
- **Mine Employment and Production — Quarterly:** 191 rows; unknown through unknown; source ID `msha-mine-production-quarterly`
- **Mine Employment and Production — Yearly:** 43 rows; unknown through unknown; source ID `msha-mine-production-yearly`
- **Mines:** 1 rows; unknown through unknown; source ID `msha-mines`
- **Noise Samples:** 98 rows; 2001-05-17 through 2018-10-22; source ID `msha-noise-samples`
- **Quartz Samples — Coal:** 64 rows; 2001-07-18 through 2019-01-16; source ID `msha-quartz-samples`
- **Violations:** 1,961 rows; 2001-05-07 through 2024-04-01; source ID `msha-violations`

## Caveats

- This is public-record decision support, not legal advice or an official MSHA record.
- Missing data can indicate no event, publication delay, an unresolved identity, or inapplicability.
- Contractor production data is entity-level and is not attributed to this mine.

## Alternate representations

- HTML: `/mines/no-58-4608884`
- JSON: `/api/v1/mines/no-58-4608884`
- Silica records, units, sample status and quarterly means: `/api/v1/mines/4608884/silica` (snapshot year by default; `?year=all` for history; `&format=csv` for all matching rows)
- Relationship JSON: `/api/v1/mines/4608884/relationships`
- MCP resource: `mine://4608884/assessment`
- Complete Title 30 corpus: `/data/title30-sections.json`