{"data":{"schemaVersion":"realm.temporal-relationships.v1","temporalSemantics":{"validTime":{"granularity":"date","bounds":"inclusive","nullStart":"start date not published in the upstream history row","nullEnd":"open-ended in the upstream history row; not independent proof of present control"},"transactionTime":{"observedAt":"2026-10-17T05:35:58.500035+00:00","meaning":"time the checksum-addressed MDRS artifacts were observed by the PostgreSQL ingestion"},"derivation":{"controllerControlsOperator":"intersection of controller and operator valid-time intervals evidenced through this mine","currentIdentity":"current controller and operator are asserted only by the MDRS Mines snapshot"}},"current":{"mine":{"type":"mine","id":"1516011","name":"Mine #4"},"operator":{"type":"operator","id":"P24317","name":"Panther Mining LLC"},"controller":{"type":"controller","id":"0041211","name":"Alpha Natural Resources, Inc."},"source":{"datasetId":"msha-mines","observedAt":"2026-10-17T05:35:58.500035+00:00"}},"edges":[{"type":"controller_controls_mine","subject":{"type":"controller","id":"C00012","name":"Ashland Inc et al"},"object":{"type":"mine","id":"1516011","name":"Mine #4"},"validFrom":"1984-10-01","validTo":null,"current":true,"derived":false,"source":{"datasetId":"msha-controller-operator-history","observedAt":"2026-10-17T05:35:58.500035+00:00","recordKey":"1516011|C00012|1984-10-01|"}},{"type":"operator_operates_mine","subject":{"type":"operator","id":"P16065","name":"Arch Of Kentucky"},"object":{"type":"mine","id":"1516011","name":"Mine #4"},"validFrom":"1987-04-01","validTo":"1991-12-25","current":false,"derived":false,"source":{"datasetId":"msha-controller-operator-history","observedAt":"2026-10-17T05:35:58.500035+00:00","recordKey":"1516011|P16065|1987-04-01|1991-12-25"}},{"type":"controller_controls_operator","subject":{"type":"controller","id":"C00012","name":"Ashland Inc et al"},"object":{"type":"operator","id":"P16065","name":"Arch Of Kentucky"},"validFrom":"1987-04-01","validTo":"1991-12-25","current":false,"derived":true,"evidenceMineId":"1516011","intervalAnomaly":false,"source":{"datasetId":"msha-controller-operator-history","observedAt":"2026-10-17T05:35:58.500035+00:00","recordKey":"1516011|P16065|1987-04-01|C00012|1984-10-01|43325"}},{"type":"controller_controls_mine","subject":{"type":"controller","id":"C14526","name":"Fugate Charles"},"object":{"type":"mine","id":"1516011","name":"Mine #4"},"validFrom":"1991-12-01","validTo":"1992-08-13","current":false,"derived":false,"source":{"datasetId":"msha-controller-operator-history","observedAt":"2026-10-17T05:35:58.500035+00:00","recordKey":"1516011|C14526|1991-12-01|1992-08-13"}},{"type":"operator_operates_mine","subject":{"type":"operator","id":"P21714","name":"Stillhouse Mining Inc"},"object":{"type":"mine","id":"1516011","name":"Mine #4"},"validFrom":"1991-12-26","validTo":"1992-08-13","current":false,"derived":false,"source":{"datasetId":"msha-controller-operator-history","observedAt":"2026-10-17T05:35:58.500035+00:00","recordKey":"1516011|P21714|1991-12-26|1992-08-13"}},{"type":"controller_controls_operator","subject":{"type":"controller","id":"C14526","name":"Fugate Charles"},"object":{"type":"operator","id":"P21714","name":"Stillhouse Mining Inc"},"validFrom":"1991-12-26","validTo":"1992-08-13","current":false,"derived":true,"evidenceMineId":"1516011","intervalAnomaly":false,"source":{"datasetId":"msha-controller-operator-history","observedAt":"2026-10-17T05:35:58.500035+00:00","recordKey":"1516011|P21714|1991-12-26|C14526|1991-12-01|93114"}},{"type":"operator_operates_mine","subject":{"type":"operator","id":"P16065","name":"Arch Of Kentucky"},"object":{"type":"mine","id":"1516011","name":"Mine #4"},"validFrom":"1992-08-14","validTo":"2000-05-14","current":false,"derived":false,"source":{"datasetId":"msha-controller-operator-history","observedAt":"2026-10-17T05:35:58.500035+00:00","recordKey":"1516011|P16065|1992-08-14|2000-05-14"}},{"type":"controller_controls_operator","subject":{"type":"controller","id":"C00012","name":"Ashland Inc et al"},"object":{"type":"operator","id":"P16065","name":"Arch Of Kentucky"},"validFrom":"1992-08-14","validTo":"2000-05-14","current":false,"derived":true,"evidenceMineId":"1516011","intervalAnomaly":false,"source":{"datasetId":"msha-controller-operator-history","observedAt":"2026-10-17T05:35:58.500035+00:00","recordKey":"1516011|P16065|1992-08-14|C00012|1984-10-01|43326"}},{"type":"controller_controls_mine","subject":{"type":"controller","id":"C07082","name":"Cumberland Resources Corporation"},"object":{"type":"mine","id":"1516011","name":"Mine #4"},"validFrom":"1999-09-01","validTo":"2010-04-18","current":false,"derived":false,"source":{"datasetId":"msha-controller-operator-history","observedAt":"2026-10-17T05:35:58.500035+00:00","recordKey":"1516011|C07082|1999-09-01|2010-04-18"}},{"type":"operator_operates_mine","subject":{"type":"operator","id":"P24481","name":"Highlands Mining & Processing Company Inc"},"object":{"type":"mine","id":"1516011","name":"Mine #4"},"validFrom":"2000-05-15","validTo":"2005-09-29","current":false,"derived":false,"source":{"datasetId":"msha-controller-operator-history","observedAt":"2026-10-17T05:35:58.500035+00:00","recordKey":"1516011|P24481|2000-05-15|2005-09-29"}},{"type":"controller_controls_mine","subject":{"type":"controller","id":"C15970","name":"Charles  Stump"},"object":{"type":"mine","id":"1516011","name":"Mine #4"},"validFrom":"2000-05-15","validTo":null,"current":true,"derived":false,"source":{"datasetId":"msha-controller-operator-history","observedAt":"2026-10-17T05:35:58.500035+00:00","recordKey":"1516011|C15970|2000-05-15|"}},{"type":"controller_controls_operator","subject":{"type":"controller","id":"C15970","name":"Charles  Stump"},"object":{"type":"operator","id":"P24481","name":"Highlands Mining & Processing Company Inc"},"validFrom":"2000-05-15","validTo":"2005-09-29","current":false,"derived":true,"evidenceMineId":"1516011","intervalAnomaly":false,"source":{"datasetId":"msha-controller-operator-history","observedAt":"2026-10-17T05:35:58.500035+00:00","recordKey":"1516011|P24481|2000-05-15|C15970|2000-05-15|97901"}},{"type":"operator_operates_mine","subject":{"type":"operator","id":"P24317","name":"Panther Mining, LLC"},"object":{"type":"mine","id":"1516011","name":"Mine #4"},"validFrom":"2005-09-30","validTo":"2006-01-24","current":false,"derived":false,"source":{"datasetId":"msha-controller-operator-history","observedAt":"2026-10-17T05:35:58.500035+00:00","recordKey":"1516011|P24317|2005-09-30|2006-01-24"}},{"type":"controller_controls_operator","subject":{"type":"controller","id":"C07082","name":"Cumberland Resources Corporation"},"object":{"type":"operator","id":"P24317","name":"Panther Mining, LLC"},"validFrom":"2005-09-30","validTo":"2006-01-24","current":false,"derived":true,"evidenceMineId":"1516011","intervalAnomaly":false,"source":{"datasetId":"msha-controller-operator-history","observedAt":"2026-10-17T05:35:58.500035+00:00","recordKey":"1516011|P24317|2005-09-30|C07082|1999-09-01|73747"}},{"type":"operator_operates_mine","subject":{"type":"operator","id":"0068264","name":"Orion Resources Inc."},"object":{"type":"mine","id":"1516011","name":"Mine #4"},"validFrom":"2006-01-25","validTo":"2007-11-21","current":false,"derived":false,"source":{"datasetId":"msha-controller-operator-history","observedAt":"2026-10-17T05:35:58.500035+00:00","recordKey":"1516011|0068264|2006-01-25|2007-11-21"}},{"type":"controller_controls_mine","subject":{"type":"controller","id":"C16057","name":"Ralph  Napier et al"},"object":{"type":"mine","id":"1516011","name":"Mine #4"},"validFrom":"2006-01-25","validTo":null,"current":true,"derived":false,"source":{"datasetId":"msha-controller-operator-history","observedAt":"2026-10-17T05:35:58.500035+00:00","recordKey":"1516011|C16057|2006-01-25|"}},{"type":"controller_controls_operator","subject":{"type":"controller","id":"C16057","name":"Ralph  Napier et al"},"object":{"type":"operator","id":"0068264","name":"Orion Resources Inc."},"validFrom":"2006-01-25","validTo":"2007-11-21","current":false,"derived":true,"evidenceMineId":"1516011","intervalAnomaly":false,"source":{"datasetId":"msha-controller-operator-history","observedAt":"2026-10-17T05:35:58.500035+00:00","recordKey":"1516011|0068264|2006-01-25|C16057|2006-01-25|98229"}},{"type":"controller_controls_operator","subject":{"type":"controller","id":"C16057","name":"John D  North et al"},"object":{"type":"operator","id":"0068264","name":"Orion Resources Inc."},"validFrom":"2006-01-25","validTo":"2007-11-21","current":false,"derived":true,"evidenceMineId":"1516011","intervalAnomaly":false,"source":{"datasetId":"msha-controller-operator-history","observedAt":"2026-10-17T05:35:58.500035+00:00","recordKey":"1516011|0068264|2006-01-25|C16057|2006-01-25|98230"}},{"type":"operator_operates_mine","subject":{"type":"operator","id":"P24317","name":"Panther Mining LLC"},"object":{"type":"mine","id":"1516011","name":"Mine #4"},"validFrom":"2007-11-22","validTo":null,"current":true,"derived":false,"source":{"datasetId":"msha-controller-operator-history","observedAt":"2026-10-17T05:35:58.500035+00:00","recordKey":"1516011|P24317|2007-11-22|"}},{"type":"controller_controls_operator","subject":{"type":"controller","id":"C07082","name":"Cumberland Resources Corporation"},"object":{"type":"operator","id":"P24317","name":"Panther Mining LLC"},"validFrom":"2007-11-22","validTo":"2010-04-18","current":false,"derived":true,"evidenceMineId":"1516011","intervalAnomaly":false,"source":{"datasetId":"msha-controller-operator-history","observedAt":"2026-10-17T05:35:58.500035+00:00","recordKey":"1516011|P24317|2007-11-22|C07082|1999-09-01|73748"}},{"type":"controller_controls_mine","subject":{"type":"controller","id":"C02508","name":"Massey Energy Company"},"object":{"type":"mine","id":"1516011","name":"Mine #4"},"validFrom":"2010-04-19","validTo":"2011-05-31","current":false,"derived":false,"source":{"datasetId":"msha-controller-operator-history","observedAt":"2026-10-17T05:35:58.500035+00:00","recordKey":"1516011|C02508|2010-04-19|2011-05-31"}},{"type":"controller_controls_operator","subject":{"type":"controller","id":"C02508","name":"Massey Energy Company"},"object":{"type":"operator","id":"P24317","name":"Panther Mining, LLC"},"validFrom":"2010-04-19","validTo":"2006-01-24","current":false,"derived":true,"evidenceMineId":"1516011","intervalAnomaly":true,"source":{"datasetId":"msha-controller-operator-history","observedAt":"2026-10-17T05:35:58.500035+00:00","recordKey":"1516011|P24317|2005-09-30|C02508|2010-04-19|59575"}},{"type":"controller_controls_operator","subject":{"type":"controller","id":"C02508","name":"Massey Energy Company"},"object":{"type":"operator","id":"P24317","name":"Panther Mining LLC"},"validFrom":"2010-04-19","validTo":"2011-05-31","current":false,"derived":true,"evidenceMineId":"1516011","intervalAnomaly":false,"source":{"datasetId":"msha-controller-operator-history","observedAt":"2026-10-17T05:35:58.500035+00:00","recordKey":"1516011|P24317|2007-11-22|C02508|2010-04-19|59576"}},{"type":"controller_controls_mine","subject":{"type":"controller","id":"0041211","name":"Alpha Natural Resources, Inc."},"object":{"type":"mine","id":"1516011","name":"Mine #4"},"validFrom":"2011-06-01","validTo":null,"current":true,"derived":false,"source":{"datasetId":"msha-controller-operator-history","observedAt":"2026-10-17T05:35:58.500035+00:00","recordKey":"1516011|0041211|2011-06-01|"}},{"type":"controller_controls_operator","subject":{"type":"controller","id":"0041211","name":"Alpha Natural Resources, Inc."},"object":{"type":"operator","id":"P24317","name":"Panther Mining, LLC"},"validFrom":"2011-06-01","validTo":"2006-01-24","current":false,"derived":true,"evidenceMineId":"1516011","intervalAnomaly":true,"source":{"datasetId":"msha-controller-operator-history","observedAt":"2026-10-17T05:35:58.500035+00:00","recordKey":"1516011|P24317|2005-09-30|0041211|2011-06-01|2241"}},{"type":"controller_controls_operator","subject":{"type":"controller","id":"0041211","name":"Alpha Natural Resources, Inc."},"object":{"type":"operator","id":"P24317","name":"Panther Mining LLC"},"validFrom":"2011-06-01","validTo":null,"current":true,"derived":true,"evidenceMineId":"1516011","intervalAnomaly":false,"source":{"datasetId":"msha-controller-operator-history","observedAt":"2026-10-17T05:35:58.500035+00:00","recordKey":"1516011|P24317|2007-11-22|0041211|2011-06-01|2242"}}],"coverage":{"historyRecords":12,"edgeCount":26,"intervalAnomalies":2,"sourceDatasetId":"msha-controller-operator-history"}},"meta":{"mineId":"1516011","dataSource":"postgres","snapshotId":"2026-10-17T05:35:58.500035+00:00","completedAt":"2026-10-17T06:17:15.228Z","sourceCount":20,"totalRows":15450873,"relationshipSemantics":"valid time; null validTo means current or open-ended in the source"}}